Let no one reply that it is enough for us to learn, as occasion
requires, some single and detached subject. In the first place we use our
own property in one way, a loan in another, and there is evidently a wide
difference between possessing what one exhibits and borrowing it. Next, the
very knowledge of many subjects sits gracefully on us, even when we are
otherwise engaged, and makes itself visible and conspicuous where you would
least expect it. Even the average citizen, and not only the learned and
critical hearer, perceives it, and forthwith showers his praises in the
acknowledgment that the man has been a genuine student, has gone through
every branch of eloquence, and is, in short, an orator. And I maintain that
the only orator is, and ever has been, one who, like a soldier equipped at
all points going to the battle-field, enters the forum armed with every
learned accomplishment.
All this is so neglected by the speakers of our
time that we detect in their pleadings the style of every-day conversation,
and unseemly and shameful deficiencies. They are ignorant of the laws, they
do not understand the senate's decrees, they actually scoff at the civil
law, while they quite
MODERN EDUCATION
PROFESSIONAL |
dread the study of philosophy, and the opinions of the
learned; and eloquence, banished, so to say, from her proper realm, is
dragged down by them into utter poverty of thought and constrained periods.
Thus she who, once mistress of all the arts, held sway with a glorious
retinue over our souls, now clipped and shorn, without state, without
honour, I had almost said without her freedom, is studied as one of the
meanest handicrafts. This then I believe to be the first and chief cause of
so marked a falling off among us from the eloquence of the old orators. If
witnesses are wanted, whom shall I name in preference to Demosthenes among
the Greeks, who is said by tradition to have been a most attentive hearer of
Plato?
Cicero too tells us, I think, in these very words, that whatever he
had achieved in eloquence he had gained, not from rhetoricians, but in the
walks of the Academy. There are other causes, some of them great and
important, which it is for you in fairness to explain, as I have now done my
part, and, after my usual way, have offended pretty many persons who, if
they happen to hear all this, will, I am sure, say that, in praising an
acquaintance with law and philosophy as a necessity for an orator, I have
been applauding my own follies.